Paddle Comparison
Bread & Butter Fat Boy vs Selkirk Vanguard Control
A side-by-side spec, value, and use-case comparison of two of the most-searched pickleball paddles. Below: the attributes each paddle wins, a full spec table, and a clear recommendation for who should buy which.
Who wins on what
Power
Selkirk Vanguard Control
Higher Swing Weight (power) (109.52 vs 115.29, +5.77)
Hand Speed
Bread & Butter Fat Boy
Lower Swing Weight (hand speed) (109.52 vs 115.29)
Sweet Spot / Forgiveness
Bread & Butter Fat Boy
Higher Twist Weight (forgiveness) (7.39 vs 5.51, +1.88)
Value
Selkirk Vanguard Control
Lower effective price ($170.99 vs $150.00, with PLAYBOOK)
Side-by-side specs
Brand
Model
Shape
Thickness
Weight
Swing Weight
Twist Weight
Play Style
Retail Price
Discount
Effective Price
See more comparisons like this — straight to your inbox
Weekly paddle picks, fresh comparisons, and exclusive discount codes.
Unsubscribe anytime · No spam · Free forever
Which paddle should you buy?
Pick the Bread & Butter Fat Boy if…
- You want faster hands — lower SW (109.52 vs 115.29) means quicker maneuvering at the kitchen.
- You want a bigger sweet spot — TW 7.39 is more forgiving on off-center hits.
- You prefer the widebody shape — different feel/reach/sweet-spot profile from the elongated.
Pick the Selkirk Vanguard Control if…
- You want more power — SW 115.29 is 5.77 points higher.
- You're price-conscious — about $21 cheaper after PLAYBOOK discount.
- You prefer the elongated shape — different feel/reach/sweet-spot profile from the widebody.
Compare other paddles in our database